Facebook Twitter Instagram
    • About
    • Subscribe
    • Contact
    • Report Library
    • Manager Login
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn RSS
    HedgeNordic
    • Home
    • Allocator Angle
    • Report Library
    • Nordic Hedge Award
      • Nominations 2021 Nordic Hedge Award
      • Rookie of the Year
      • Jury Board
      • Historic Winners
      • Statistics
    • Nordic Hedge Index
    • Webinars & Podcasts
    HedgeNordic

    One Value Strategy, Two Sources of Alpha

    Eugeniu GuzunBy Eugeniu Guzun30/10/2019No Comments
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Email

    Stockholm (HedgeNordic) – Value investing – buying stocks priced cheaply relative to fundamentals – has simply not worked for most investors over the last decade. “If the last ten years have been challenging to the value investor, then the last five have been pure torture,” exclaims Pasi Havia (pictured), the portfolio manager of systematic value-focused fund HCP Quant.

    The fund was launched under the umbrella of Finnish asset manager Helsinki Capital Partners in June of 2014, at a rather difficult time for most value investors. HCP Quant experienced both up and down years since inception, but Havia predicts (and hopes for) a bright future ahead for value investing. “The underperformance of value investing cannot go on forever; things tend to mean revert,” claims Havia.

    “The underperformance of value investing cannot go on forever; things tend to mean revert.”

    One Strategy, Two Sources of Alpha, Perhaps Three

    HCP Quant is a quant-heavy systematic value fund managed by Pasi Havia, who, in a previous life, was one of Finland’s most well-known investment bloggers. The fund currently maintains a concentrated portfolio of 20 cheap stocks from all around the world. HCP Quant mainly focuses on small- and mid-cap stocks, because “these segments of equity markets are often under-analysed,” according to Havia. The fund’s investable universe, therefore, covers companies with market capitalisations starting from €100 million up to €10 billion.

    “Most companies on stock exchanges are small- and mid-sized companies,” says Havia, who emphasises that his systematic approach of picking stocks enables him to cover the massive universe of small-cap stocks. “This space is under-analysed, which hopefully gives me an edge,” argues the portfolio manager, who has a background in IT and programming. “There are so many professionals doing a really good job at analysing companies in the large-cap space, so my edge is pretty much inexistent in that world using my quantitative strategy,” acknowledges Havia.

    In essence, HCP Quant attempts to capture both the so-called “size premium” – which states that smaller-cap stocks outperform large-caps on average over time – and the “value premium.” Furthermore, inexpensiveness is not the sole parameter in HCP Quant’s systematic approach to investing. The fund searches for cheap stocks among a pool of high-quality stocks in the small-cap space.

    To define, quantify and identify quality, Havia relies on the so-called Piotroski F-Score. This technique spits out a score between zero and nine that quantifies the strength of a company’s financial position. According to Havia, the Piotroski F-Score “considers nine different characteristics of company fundamentals” such as return on assets, gross margin, asset turnover, among others, where each criterion has a binary value of either one or zero. “I use the Piotroski F-Score as a quality check of the companies I invest in,” explains Havia.

    Because the Piotroski F-Score relies on a considerable volume of accounting data, Havia uses a separate technique to check the possibility of earnings manipulation. “I need to be sure that the numbers that I incorporate in the quantitative model are accurate and are not cooked numbers,” says Havia. The portfolio manager uses the Beneish M-Score to safeguard against manipulated earnings. “Using the Beneish M-Score, which gives the probability of a company cooking its books, I make sure that I can trust the data I am feeding my model with.”

    From a pool of smaller-sized companies with a Piotroski F-Score between seven and nine, HCP Quant builds a concentrated portfolio of, what he considers, extremely cheap stocks. Companies that pass HCP Quant’s investment criteria have low valuation on several metrics such as price-to-earnings, price-to-cash flow, price-to-sales and enterprise value to EBITDA. “In the end, I rank all stocks using one valuation metric,” with the cheapest stocks ending up in the concentrated portfolio of between 20 to 30 stocks. The fund’s existing portfolio of 20 stocks trades at 4.23 times cash flow, 7.83 times earnings and sports an annualised dividend yield of 5.66 percent. Anyone seen anything cheaper?

    Behavioural Biases and Risk Management

    Because humans are prone to behavioural biases and some value stocks are “unsexy and look scary,” Havia executes his quantitative value investing strategy in a systematic way. “Quite often, we as humans, are the enemies of ourselves,” claims Havia. For that reason, the portfolio manager avoids market timing by maintaining a fixed holding period of six months for each position. He also uses equal weightings in the portfolio, arguing that “I am not saying that this stock is better than the other one.” Because “I do not attempt to engage in market timing, I partly re-balance the portfolio every month,” says Havia. “Every month, I am selling a few stocks and adding a few new ones.”

    Because there is no discretionary approach to portfolio management at HCP Quant, Havia has a safeguard to reduce volatility in the fund’s returns. Specifically, the portfolio manager uses a stop loss of 20 percent that “can trigger a sale even though the position did not stay in the portfolio for six months.” As Havia explains, “the reason we ended up using the stop loss is partly because of risk management.” If HCP Quant had not used a stop loss, the volatility in the portfolio’s returns would have been higher. “The stop loss is an important part of risk management because my portfolio already has high volatility stemming from the small-cap-focus.”

    Thoughts on Value Investing

    For Havia, “value investing means low valuations.” There is a wide range of valuation metrics one can look at, “but that does not really matter for me,” reckons Havia. “No matter which valuation metrics you used in the past decade, you most probably did not end up delivering good results anyway,” he argues.

    The underperformance of value stocks is partly attributable to the zero-interest-rate environment, argues Havia, who adds that “there is a lot of cheap money flowing into high-tech companies that can fund research and growth easily.” Another reason stems from the growing volume of capital flowing into exchange-traded funds and index funds, which tend to favour large-cap stocks at the expense of smaller-sized companies. “These days so many investors put money into ETFs and index funds without considering valuations,” says Havia. “Maybe I am biased because I manage a value investing fund myself, but to me, it is a little bit worrying that there is a huge number of investors who do not really care about valuations.”

    “Maybe I am biased because I manage a value investing fund myself, but to me, it is a little bit worrying that there is a huge number of investors who do not really care about valuations.”

    “The valuation spread between value and growth stocks is at the same level as during the tech bubble at the beginning of the century,” argues Havia. “I do not know when this gap is going to disappear, but value investing still makes sense.” Everything is about probabilities to Havia. He looks at the world through probabilities, and he approaches investing with probabilities. “For me, it is more probable that low-valued stocks will do better than non-value stocks over time,” concludes Havia.

    Share. Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Email
    Previous ArticleHF Launches Fall in Number
    Next Article Young Hedge Funds Do Better
    Eugeniu Guzun

    Eugeniu Guzun serves as a data analyst responsible for maintaining and gatekeeping the Nordic Hedge Index, and as a journalist covering the Nordic hedge fund industry for HedgeNordic. Eugeniu completed his Master’s degree at the Stockholm School of Economics in 2018.

    Related Posts

    AIM Capital Hires Portfolio Manager

    A Fundamental Formula: Focus on Valuation

    Gladiator Leaves the Colosseum

    Add A Comment

    Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

    Time limit is exhausted. Please reload CAPTCHA.

    Most read today:
    • Blockification
    • Systematic Strategies Thrive in the New Inflationary Climate
    • The Winners at the 2021 Nordic Hedge Award
    • Velliv Makes Further Inroads into Fintech
    • Revisiting Trend-Following CTAs
    • New Theme: Real Income Destruction
    • In-Depth: Inflation Protection

    New Theme: Real Income Destruction

    17/05/2022

    Blockification

    16/05/2022

    The Inflation Puzzle

    12/05/2022

    Systematic Strategies Thrive in the New Inflationary Climate

    12/05/2022
    Promotion:
    Video: Manager Interviews
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tni7dQvQrmo

    Subscribe to our newsletter

    HedgeNordic: Your Single Access Point to the Nordic Hedge Fund Industry!

    Check your inbox now to confirm your subscription.

    Most read articles this week:
    • Systematic Strategies Thrive in the New Inflationary Climate
    • Follow Your Favourite Hedge Fund
    • Month in Review – April 2022
    • Evli’s Forest Fund Ready to Deploy Capital
    • AFII Appoints Head of Portfolio Strategy
    • Blockification
    • Recent
    • NHX
    • In Depth

    New Theme: Real Income Destruction

    17/05/2022

    Velliv Makes Further Inroads into Fintech

    17/05/2022

    Blockification

    16/05/2022

    Month in Review – April 2022

    12/05/2022

    Month in Review – April 2022

    12/05/2022

    Follow Your Favourite Hedge Fund

    11/05/2022

    Month in Review – March 2022

    13/04/2022

    Month in Review – February 2022

    10/03/2022

    New Theme: Real Income Destruction

    17/05/2022

    Blockification

    16/05/2022

    The Inflation Puzzle

    12/05/2022

    Systematic Strategies Thrive in the New Inflationary Climate

    12/05/2022
    Newsletter Subscription:
    Most Recent Posts:

    New Theme: Real Income Destruction

    17/05/2022

    Velliv Makes Further Inroads into Fintech

    17/05/2022

    Blockification

    16/05/2022

    Month in Review – April 2022

    12/05/2022

    The Inflation Puzzle

    12/05/2022
    Publisher

    Nordic Business Media AB
    Corporate No.: 556838-6170
    BOX 7285
    SE-103 89 Stockholm, Sweden

    VAT No.: SE-556838617001
    Tel.:+46 (0) 8 5333 8688
    Mob.: +46 (0) 7 06566688
    Email: info@hedgenordic.com

    STAY INFORMED

    HedgeNordic: Your Single Access Point to the Nordic Hedge Fund Industry!

    Subscribe to our newsletter:

    Check your inbox now to confirm your subscription.

    RSS Hedge Fund Job Digest
    • Fund Controller 17/05/2022
    • Operations/Process Reengineering 17/05/2022
    • Global Macro Structuring Analyst/Associate 17/05/2022
    • Director - Fund Accounting 17/05/2022
    • Vice President – Credit Risk Analyst Banks 17/05/2022
    • Fund Accountant - Analyst 17/05/2022
    • Director – Credit Officer 17/05/2022
    • Investment Fund Accounting Supervisor 17/05/2022

    Copyright © 2022 Nordic Business Media AB

    © 2022 Nordic Business Media AB
    • About
    • Cookie Policy
    • Privacy Policy

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

    We are using cookies to give you the best experience on our website.

    HedgeNordic
    Powered by  GDPR Cookie Compliance
    Privacy Overview

    This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.

    Strictly Necessary Cookies

    Strictly Necessary Cookie should be enabled at all times so that we can save your preferences for cookie settings.

    If you disable this cookie, we will not be able to save your preferences. This means that every time you visit this website you will need to enable or disable cookies again.