- Advertisement -
- Advertisement -

Related

Skin in the Game Isn’t Enough

Report: Alternative Fixed Income

- Advertisement -

Stockholm (HedgeNordic) – Capital commitment by fund managers is an effective way to align the interests of managers and investors. Hedge fund managers with more “skin in the game” do outperform those with less capital commitment, but the outperformance “comes at the cost of limited entry by outside investors,” recent research shows.

According to a study by Arpit Gupta and Kunal Sachdeva published in July this year, “funds with more insider investment outperform other funds within the same family.” However, the researchers argue that “this relationship is driven by managerial decisions to invest capital in their least-scalable strategies and restrict the entry of new outsider capital into these funds.” Whereas hedge fund managers contribute substantial personal capital into their funds, which can better align incentives between managers and investors, “managers may also strategically allocate their private capital in ways that negatively affect investors.”

In the study, Arpit Gupta and Kunal Sachdeva examine three hypotheses:

  • Hedge fund managers allocate their capital to less-scalable strategies;
  • Managers restrict access to outside investors in these funds;
  • Insider funds outperform on a risk-adjusted basis.

First, the authors find that managers invest capital in the least-scalable strategies. Second, they find that managers limit access to outside investors into these least-scalable funds, “sometimes closing access to outside investors completely.” And third, funds with higher internal investment deliver greater excess returns by taking on less leverage and less exposure to illiquid assets, which suggests that the outperformance is not attributable to hidden risks. Yet, these funds are offered on a limited basis to outside investors. According to the results, a fund with a one-standard-deviation increase in insider investment relative to the mean is associated with an additional 1.4-1.7 percent in excess return per year.

The authors also find evidence that greater “skin in the game” incentivizes managers to better manage the so-called size-performance trade-off by crowding out outside capital. Funds with higher insider investment are less likely to accept inflows following positive returns and are more likely to be closed to outside investors completely. The authors conclude that “the joint relationship between internal investment, fund flows, and performance suggests that funds better manage capacity constraints when managers have personal capital at stake, leading to superior returns at the expense of fewer managed investments.” These findings show that “hedge funds face capacity constraints in their operations, and differentially allocate capital across their funds to maximize profits, depending on the mix of inside and outside capital.”

Photo: YorkBerlin—shutterstock.com

Subscribe to HedgeBrev, HedgeNordic’s weekly newsletter, and never miss the latest news!

Our newsletter is sent once a week, every Friday.

Eugeniu Guzun
Eugeniu Guzun
Eugeniu Guzun serves as a data analyst responsible for maintaining and gatekeeping the Nordic Hedge Index, and as a journalist covering the Nordic hedge fund industry for HedgeNordic. Eugeniu completed his Master’s degree at the Stockholm School of Economics in 2018. Write to Eugeniu Guzun at eugene@hedgenordic.com

Latest Articles

Infrastructure’s Role in Europe’s Transformation

As Europe accelerates its transition toward a greener and more digital future, infrastructure investment has become a cornerstone of this transformation. However, a funding...

Capital Four Reaches Hard Cap for Fifth Private Debt Vintage

Copenhagen-based credit specialist Capital Four has reached the hard cap of €3 billion for its fifth private debt vintage, Private Debt V – Senior....

Othania Introduces UCITS Version of All-Weather Strategy

Danish boutique asset manager Othania has assumed management of the UCITS-structured fund ØU Invest Balance KL, which will be rebranded as Othania Stabil UCITS...

Hilbert Expands Asset Management Arm

Hilbert Group, which operates an asset management business specializing in hedge funds focused on digital assets, has completed the acquisition and integration of digital...

Elementa Reaches All-Time High on 10th Anniversary

Elementa, the long/short equity fund managed by Marcus Wahlberg, was named “Rookie of the Year” at the 2015 Nordic Hedge Award, recognizing it as...

Private Markets and Equity Exposure Top Priorities for Nordic Investors

Nuveen has published the results of its annual Global Institutional Investor Survey, revealing that 58 percent of the 40 surveyed Nordic investors plan to...

Allocator Interviews

In-Depth: Megatrends

Voices

Request for Proposal

- Advertisement -