The challenging private equity environment, marked by higher financing costs, slower distributions and difficult exit conditions, is putting greater pressure on managers to demonstrate their ability to create value in underlying businesses. For Afa Försäkring, operational improvements have long been central to private equity manager selection, but the current market makes this focus more important than ever. Having invested in private equity since 1998, the Swedish insurer is drawing on decades of experience to navigate the cycle, prioritizing proven managers, disciplined underwriting and sustainable value creation over returns driven by leverage and rising valuations.
Private equity has been a significant part of Afa’s investment programme since 1998, serving as “an important driver of long-term returns and providing access to companies and value creation opportunities that are not always available in public markets,” according to Marie Lindskog, Head of Alternative Investments at Afa Försäkring. “It also diversifies the portfolio’s sources of return and risk exposures, giving us access to smaller companies that choose to remain privately owned or for which a public listing is not a practical option,” she continues. “These businesses offer opportunities to create value through growth and operational improvements, complementing the investments we hold in public markets.” The objective is to build a well-diversified programme that delivers attractive risk-adjusted returns over time, supported by patience, discipline and strong manager relationships.
“These businesses offer opportunities to create value through growth and operational improvements, complementing the investments we hold in public markets.”
Marie Lindskog, Head of Alternative Investments at Afa Försäkring.
A More Demanding Market
Delivering on these long-term objectives also requires navigating a private equity market that has undergone significant changes in recent years. “The private equity environment is definitely more demanding than it was a few years ago. Financing costs are higher, distributions have been slow, and exit environments have become more complex and difficult,” explains Lindskog. While developments such as continuation vehicles have created additional exit opportunities, they have also added complexity to the market.
“The private equity environment is definitely more demanding than it was a few years ago. Financing costs are higher, distributions have been slow, and exit environments have become more complex and difficult.”
Marie Lindskog, Head of Alternative Investments at Afa Försäkring.
The more challenging environment has exposed managers who relied on low borrowing costs and financial engineering to drive valuation multiples higher, rather than focusing on operational value creation. Afa has consequently intensified its scrutiny of how managers create value within their portfolio companies. “To some extent, this makes manager selection more demanding, but that is not necessarily a bad thing. There is now greater emphasis on operational value creation. My expectation is that this more challenging environment will ultimately create a healthier private equity market,” says Lindskog.
“The focus on assessing managers ability to create value has always been part of our process, but it has become even more important in the current environment.”
Marie Lindskog, Head of Alternative Investments at Afa Försäkring.
For Afa Försäkring, this is less a change in investment philosophy than a test of an established principle. “Operational improvement has always been an important part of our due diligence when assessing new managers,” Lindskog says. However, the current environment has made the link between business performance and investment returns more apparent. “A well-managed business in which value has been created should be better positioned to attract buyers, even in a demanding market,” she explains. “The focus on assessing managers ability to create value has always been part of our process, but it has become even more important in the current environment.”
Sector Expertise Under Scrutiny
The tougher environment has also exposed differences across sectors. Healthcare, which attracted a large number of private equity managers in recent years, is one of the areas that has been challenged and many generalist managers have reduced their investments in that sector, although Lindskog sees signs of improvement. “Deep sector expertise and a clear understanding of the underlying businesses have become particularly important,” she says, noting that managers who have encountered problems may find it harder to justify continued investment in the sector to their investors.
Technology and software face a different set of challenges. Afa Försäkring has limited exposure to software-only funds, but Lindskog points to artificial intelligence and broader market pressures as factors challenging the valuation models underpinning some investments. “It raises question about whether those businesses can grow as fast as their valuations implied when they were acquired,” she argues.
“We tend to favor managers that are active in at least two sectors, but really specialized in those sectors.”
Marie Lindskog, Head of Alternative Investments at Afa Försäkring.
Afa Försäkring continues to favor managers with deep expertise in the areas in which they invest. “We tend to favor managers that are active in at least two sectors, but really specialized in those sectors,” Lindskog explains. In the current environment, Lindskog observes that managers are spending more time scrutinizing potential acquisitions and assessing whether they can create enough value to achieve a higher exit price four or five years later.
Proven Managers and the Mid-Market
Afa Försäkring’s manager selection process favors established managers with a demonstrated ability to generate returns and realize investments. “We rarely consider funds smaller than $1 billion or €1 billion, and we rarely invest in first-time funds,” Lindskog says. The insurer typically commits to a manager’s third or fourth fund, when it can assess both the track record of realized exits and overall returns. While Afa Försäkring maintains a few core relationships with larger buyout managers to provide building blocks for the portfolio, it sees the mid-market as its main source of alpha. “We have identified that the mid-market is very attractive,” she says, referring to spending most time on funds typically sized at around two billion to five billion U.S. dollars, where Afa Försäkring concentrates much of its research and due diligence.
“We spend a lot of time getting to know managers. Sometimes we meet them over several years before the timing is right, but then a situation arises where we see an opportunity to commit.”
Marie Lindskog, Head of Alternative Investments at Afa Försäkring.
Beyond fund size and track record, Afa Försäkring places considerable emphasis on the investment team, its structure and the GP’s alignment with investors. Building relationships with managers well before committing capital is an important part of the process. “We spend a lot of time getting to know managers. Sometimes we meet them over several years before the timing is right, but then a situation arises where we see an opportunity to commit,” Lindskog explains. Meeting managers outside fundraising periods allows Afa Försäkring to develop a deeper understanding of their approach and assess whether a partnership makes sense when the right opportunity arises.
Recovery Depends on Exits, Not Market Timing
Looking ahead, a recovery in private equity will depend partly on a revival in exit activity, with more sponsor-to-sponsor transactions, strategic sales and IPOs helping unlock value across portfolios. “If more exits come through, that would definitely unlock some of that potential,” Lindskog says. Functioning financing markets will be important in supporting this revival in activity. With banks, public markets and private credit all providing sources of financing, she believes the necessary infrastructure is in place.
“For us, it’s about thoughtful portfolio construction with a long-term perspective, consistent pacing, and spending time finding the right managers rather than making significant changes to our approach.”
Marie Lindskog, Head of Alternative Investments at Afa Försäkring.
Rather than trying to time the market, Afa Försäkring focuses on maintaining a consistent investment pace and building a portfolio that can deliver returns over the long term. “For us, it’s about thoughtful portfolio construction with a long-term perspective, consistent pacing, and spending time finding the right managers rather than making significant changes to our approach,” Lindskog concludes. “That approach has been key to the long-term success of Afa Försäkring’s private equity programme.”
