Facebook Twitter Instagram
    • About
    • Subscribe
    • Contact
    • Report Library
    • Manager Login
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn RSS
    HedgeNordic
    • Home
    • Allocator Angle
    • Report Library
    • Nordic Hedge Award
      • Nominations 2021 Nordic Hedge Award
      • Rookie of the Year
      • Jury Board
      • Historic Winners
      • Statistics
    • Nordic Hedge Index
    • Webinars & Podcasts
    HedgeNordic

    O Value, Where Art Thou?

    Eugeniu GuzunBy Eugeniu Guzun28/11/2019No Comments
    Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Email

    By Peter Lindahl of Evli: Getting the timing right is always a struggle as irrational periods can last for a good while. But value today is extremely cheap in relative terms and sentiment towards value is extremely pessimistic — and we strongly believe it may be a sensible time to buy value stocks both for the short-term and the long run.

    I started my financial career as a young analyst during the mid-1990s in the dry heat of a booming California. Even though the technology sector by then had started to inflate the IT bubble, one of my first job tasks was highly unexpected: to construct a list of cheap stocks based on different valuation measures such as the price-earnings (P/E) and price-to-book (P/B) ratios (a cumbersome task for an analyst in a time period when “the Internet” was a new thing and online databases did not exist). A value case that could interest smart clients, looking to buy low, sell high. A more senior colleague tried to instruct me to look for cheap stocks the “Warren Buffett way.” “You better check out his investment style,” he strongly advised me.

    The Ups and Downs

    Buffett was already quite popular in the 1990s, but back then his devoted followers were more of a ”value cult.” Later, on December 5th in 1996, Alan Greenspan, the conspicuous Fed Chief at the time, warned that the stock market was suffering from irrational exuberance. In other words, he claimed that the market had entered a mania phase and was becoming too expensive overall. Value investors agreed. However, Greenspan’s timing was everything but accurate. Stock markets were in for one of the most exuberant periods in history, and it took more than three years of impressive price gains before the bubble burst.

    Value stocks suffered one of its worst periods in the late 1990s, compared to the rest of the stock market, but especially against expensive growth stocks. Increasingly bullish investors lost faith in value — “value investing is dead,” many claimed (see Figure 1).

    Figure 1: Value vs. Growth performance (USA, 1995-2000). Source: Evli, Bloomberg, S&P, total returns in USD.

    Lo and behold, the early 2000s turned out to be one of the most powerful periods for value stocks in relative terms. Warren Buffett and his cohort of value fans were back. Eventually, the ethos of value investing grew bigger and stronger as Buffett gathered tens of thousands of investors to the middle of nowhere in Omaha every year. Then came the global financial crisis.

    Value investing is, without doubt, the most debated investment style among equity investors across the globe. The underperformance since the GFC has created new doubts on whether value is a sensible investment style, not to mention it being a rewarded factor for the long-term investor altogether. Investors in recent years have fled in masses to the more defensive growth stocks which have performed well not only in the past 1-2 years but also over the past ten years. But there’s a mounting issue with growth stocks — they have become exceedingly expensive, while value stocks are still cheap.

    The Short History of Value Investing

    The foundation of value as an investment style was laid out by Benjamin Graham and David Dodd in Security Analysis which was published already in 1934. Subsequently, Graham cemented this style of investing in Intelligent Investor in 1949. Both books have influenced investors around the world, labelling Graham as the “father of value investing.” This style of investing influenced the young student Warren Buffett, who already in the 1950s took up practicing value investing according to the disciplines he acquired as Graham’s student.

    Over recent decades, a well-established body of academic literature has demonstrated a strong case for the value premium. Basu [1977] was the first empirical researcher to demonstrate that value stocks generate higher returns than the market. Fama and French [1992, 1993] presented the value premium in an asset pricing model, labelled the three-factor model (FF3). Their work was in many ways ground-breaking and established the path academic research transformed itself around asset pricing in general, and factor research more specifically.

    The Long-Term Case

    Despite the bad periods, the value factor (cheap stocks) displays strong evidence of outperformance against growth stocks (expensive stocks) over long periods as well as across markets in the United States, Europe and Asia. Furthermore, the value premium is present across asset classes, e.g. in bonds and currencies.

    According to data by professor Kenneth French, US value stocks have outperformed growth stocks by 3.1 percent per annum between 1926-2019 (see Figure 2). This includes all the poor value periods in history (blue arrows show the periods of over -20 percent relative underperformance). Hence, long-term value investors have got rewarded. Warren Buffett is a living example of this, although all his performance has not only been driven by the value factor.

    Figure 2: Value vs. Growth performance (USA, 1926-2019). Source: Evli, Kenneth French website; US equity market. Time period 07/1926-07/2019. Blue arrows over -20% relative drawdowns. Log scale. For illustrative purposes only.

    Even in the more objective perspective as a systematic investor, value is certainly one of the more compelling factors. Value tends to have a low correlation to other factors, especially momentum. Hence, value possesses a great deal of diversification benefits – for any investor.

    The Present Case for Value

    Observing historical performance, occasionally value tends to experience even long periods of underperformance. Such as in the late 1990s or more recently after the GFC. Fast forward to today, the difference in valuation levels between (inexpensive) value and (expensive) growth stocks in Europe is as extreme as it was in 2000 at the peak of the IT bubble. This goes for P/E, P/B or price-to-free-cash flow ratios. Similar extreme levels can be recognised in US and global markets, as well (see Figure 3).

    Figure 3: European value priced at 1/3 of growth stocks (similar extreme discount levels as in 2000). Source: Evli, Bloomberg, MSCI.

    Getting the timing right is always a struggle as irrational periods can last for a good while. But value is today extremely cheap in relative terms and sentiment towards value is extremely pessimistic — and we strongly believe it may be a sensible time to buy value stocks both for the short-term and the long run.

    For the longer-term investor, we think value should be one of the building blocks in a strategic equity portfolio. Not only does empirical research show robust evidence of the value premium in the past, but both risk-based and behavioural theories make sensible cases why value stocks will continue to outperform markets in the long run.

    In September, over the course of 1-2 weeks, a rotation in markets occurred as investors switched from styles such as momentum to value stocks. There was an especially large move upwards in value over a couple of days, which may have been an early sign implying that value is poised for outperformance in the near term. In summary, we believe the more recent technical data (extreme cheapness) and arguments advocated by academic research supporting both a tactical and strategic case for value.

     

    This article featured in HedgeNordic’s Special Report on Equity Strategies.

    Share. Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Email
    Previous ArticleBring Them Home
    Next Article Man Group Nordic Institutional Investor Breakfast 
    Eugeniu Guzun

    Eugeniu Guzun serves as a data analyst responsible for maintaining and gatekeeping the Nordic Hedge Index, and as a journalist covering the Nordic hedge fund industry for HedgeNordic. Eugeniu completed his Master’s degree at the Stockholm School of Economics in 2018.

    Related Posts

    Real Assets: AP4’s True “Alternative”

    European Real Estate in the New Economic Climate

    Specialty Finance in Emerging Markets: The Goldilocks Strategy

    Add A Comment

    Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

    Time limit is exhausted. Please reload CAPTCHA.

    Most read today:
    • Mortgage Funds – Alternative Fixed Income, or Just the New T...
    • Lower no Longer: Cash & Carry in the Emissions Markets
    • Adding Leverage to a Fund Does Not Always Increase Risk
    • Nordic Hedge Award – Main
    • One-Stop Institutional Shop for Crypto
    • Tidan is Different
    • In-Depth: Inflation Protection

    Ukraine, Supply-Chain Shortages and Soaring Prices – Accelerators of Sustainable Development

    18/05/2022

    New Theme: Real Income Destruction

    17/05/2022

    Blockification

    16/05/2022

    The Inflation Puzzle

    12/05/2022
    Promotion:
    Video: Manager Interviews
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tni7dQvQrmo

    Subscribe to our newsletter

    HedgeNordic: Your Single Access Point to the Nordic Hedge Fund Industry!

    Check your inbox now to confirm your subscription.

    Most read articles this week:
    • Real Assets: AP4’s True “Alternative”
    • Special Report: Private Markets
    • European Real Estate in the New Economic Climate
    • PFA Hires PM from Hedge Fund Space
    • ESG Implementation in Mandatum’s Private Debt Program
    • Month in Review – May 2022
    • Recent
    • NHX
    • In Depth

    Procrastinated Risk is Knocking on the Door

    23/06/2022

    PFA Hires PM from Hedge Fund Space

    22/06/2022

    Month in Review – May 2022

    22/06/2022

    Real Assets: AP4’s True “Alternative”

    20/06/2022

    Month in Review – May 2022

    22/06/2022

    Month in Review – April 2022

    12/05/2022

    Follow Your Favourite Hedge Fund

    11/05/2022

    Month in Review – March 2022

    13/04/2022

    Ukraine, Supply-Chain Shortages and Soaring Prices – Accelerators of Sustainable Development

    18/05/2022

    New Theme: Real Income Destruction

    17/05/2022

    Blockification

    16/05/2022

    The Inflation Puzzle

    12/05/2022
    Newsletter Subscription:
    Most Recent Posts:

    Procrastinated Risk is Knocking on the Door

    23/06/2022

    PFA Hires PM from Hedge Fund Space

    22/06/2022

    Month in Review – May 2022

    22/06/2022

    Real Assets: AP4’s True “Alternative”

    20/06/2022

    European Real Estate in the New Economic Climate

    20/06/2022
    Publisher

    Nordic Business Media AB
    Corporate No.: 556838-6170
    BOX 7285
    SE-103 89 Stockholm, Sweden

    VAT No.: SE-556838617001
    Tel.:+46 (0) 8 5333 8688
    Mob.: +46 (0) 7 06566688
    Email: info@hedgenordic.com

    STAY INFORMED

    HedgeNordic: Your Single Access Point to the Nordic Hedge Fund Industry!

    Subscribe to our newsletter:

    Check your inbox now to confirm your subscription.

    RSS Hedge Fund Job Digest
    • Fund Quant Developer 24/06/2022
    • Corporate Accountant 24/06/2022
    • Institutional Sales – Assistant Vice President 24/06/2022
    • Quality Controls Analyst 24/06/2022
    • Counterparty Credit Risk VP 24/06/2022
    • Assistant Trust Officer 24/06/2022
    • Assistant Vice President – Residential Mortgage Analytics 24/06/2022
    • Senior Lead Analyst 24/06/2022

    Copyright © 2022 Nordic Business Media AB

    © 2022 Nordic Business Media AB
    • About
    • Cookie Policy
    • Privacy Policy

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

    We are using cookies to give you the best experience on our website.

    HedgeNordic
    Powered by  GDPR Cookie Compliance
    Privacy Overview

    This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.

    Strictly Necessary Cookies

    Strictly Necessary Cookie should be enabled at all times so that we can save your preferences for cookie settings.

    If you disable this cookie, we will not be able to save your preferences. This means that every time you visit this website you will need to enable or disable cookies again.